Speciesism, arbitrariness and moral illusionspost by stijnbruers · 2018-12-17T22:30:59.940Z · score: 8 (3 votes) · EA · GW · None comments
This is a link post for https://stijnbruers.wordpress.com/2018/12/13/speciesism-arbitrariness-and-moral-illusions/
In this article I present several topics related to the moral philosophy of animal rights:
- Defining moral illusions: persistent intuitive moral judgments that violate our strongest and deepest moral values.
- Detecting moral illusions: looking for unwanted arbitrariness (picking an element from a set without following a rule and with the reasonable objection of at least someone).
- Defining the most fundamental principle in ethics, based on the idea to avoid unwanted arbitrariness: for every choice you make, you have to be able to give a justifying rule of which you can consistently want that everyone follows that rule in all possible situations.
- Defining discrimination: treating A better than B in a way that B cannot want, based on arbitrary criteria and without tolerating swapping positions (treating A like B and vice versa).
- Arguing why speciesism (valuing humans higher than non-human animals) is a kind of discrimination because it involves unwanted arbitrariness.
- Defining the right to bodily autonomy: we are not allowed to use someone else’s body against that person’s will.
- Arguing why this right to bodily autonomy is the most fundamental right, because it does not impose negative externalities (a certain kind of costs) on others.
- Arguing why veganism is a moral duty based on the principles of antidiscrimination and the right to bodily autonomy.
- Arguing why speciesism is a persistent moral illusion, with the example of wild animal suffering.
- Arguing why we should start doing scientific research in welfare biology to look for safe and effective methods to intervene in nature to improve wild animal well-being.
- Explaining the connection between pseudo-ethics and pseudoscience: both involve avoidable and unwanted arbitrariness.
The full article can be downloaded here: Speciesism, arbitrariness and moral illusions
Comments sorted by top scores.