Posts

Where are the cool places to live where there is still *no* EA community? Bonus points if there is unlikely to be one in the future 2022-05-11T08:33:19.105Z

Comments

Comment by nananana.nananana.heyhey.anon on Bad Omens in Current Community Building · 2022-05-21T14:54:14.549Z · EA · GW

I agree with you. Yet I bristle when people who I don’t know well start putting forth arguments to me about what is good/bad for me, especially in a context where I wasn’t expecting it.

I’m much more accustomed to people thinking that moral relativism is polite, at least at first.

Moral relativism can be annoying, but putting forth strong moral positions at eg a fresher’s fair does feel like something that missionaries do.

Comment by nananana.nananana.heyhey.anon on Bad Omens in Current Community Building · 2022-05-21T14:25:00.150Z · EA · GW

Appreciate your comments, Aaron.

You say: But I am confident that leaders' true desire is "find people who have great epistemics [and are somewhat aligned]", not "find people who are extremely aligned [and have okay epistemics]".

I think that’s true for a lot of hires. But does that hold equally true when you think of hiring community builders specifically?

In my experience (5 ish people), leaders’ epistemic criteria seem less stringent for community building. Familiarity with EA, friendliness, and productivity seemed more salient.

Comment by nananana.nananana.heyhey.anon on Bad Omens in Current Community Building · 2022-05-21T14:06:46.662Z · EA · GW

I agree with you, and I think this somewhat supports the OPs concern.

Are most uni groups capable of producing or critiquing empirical work about their group, or about EA or about their cause areas of choice? Are they incentivized to do so at all?

Sometimes yes, but mostly no.

Comment by nananana.nananana.heyhey.anon on Bad Omens in Current Community Building · 2022-05-21T13:59:22.647Z · EA · GW

Strong +1. This feels much more like the correct use of student groups to me.

Comment by nananana.nananana.heyhey.anon on Bad Omens in Current Community Building · 2022-05-21T13:53:14.011Z · EA · GW

Re: “there have been cases of really great organizers springing up after just an intro fellowship.”

I definitely believe this can happen and am glad you allow for that. What makes someone seem really great — epistemics, alignment/buy-in, skill in a relevant area of study, __?

Comment by nananana.nananana.heyhey.anon on Bad Omens in Current Community Building · 2022-05-21T13:33:39.089Z · EA · GW

I agree and think this is an argument for investing in cause specific groups rather than generalized community building.

Comment by nananana.nananana.heyhey.anon on Where are the cool places to live where there is still *no* EA community? Bonus points if there is unlikely to be one in the future · 2022-05-21T12:30:11.329Z · EA · GW

This seems like good advice

Comment by nananana.nananana.heyhey.anon on "Big tent" effective altruism is very important (particularly right now) · 2022-05-21T11:08:39.123Z · EA · GW

Would you have this same reaction if you saw Luke and Max or GWWC/CEA as equals and peers? Maybe so! It seems like you think this as the head of CEA talking down to the OP. Max and Luke seem to know each other though; I read Max’s comment as a quick flag between equals that there’s a disagreement here, but writing it on the forum instead of an email means the rest of us get to participate a bit more in the conversation too.

Comment by nananana.nananana.heyhey.anon on Where are the cool places to live where there is still *no* EA community? Bonus points if there is unlikely to be one in the future · 2022-05-11T15:28:54.195Z · EA · GW

I am worried about alienation but I feel alienated where I currently am too so a new scene might not be much different.

Comment by nananana.nananana.heyhey.anon on Where are the cool places to live where there is still *no* EA community? Bonus points if there is unlikely to be one in the future · 2022-05-11T15:27:37.634Z · EA · GW

I’m curious what are the things that would lead to you encouraging someone in this direction?

Comment by nananana.nananana.heyhey.anon on Where are the cool places to live where there is still *no* EA community? Bonus points if there is unlikely to be one in the future · 2022-05-11T15:26:12.199Z · EA · GW

It does seem reversible though, and might be worth a shot.

Comment by nananana.nananana.heyhey.anon on Where are the cool places to live where there is still *no* EA community? Bonus points if there is unlikely to be one in the future · 2022-05-11T15:25:12.886Z · EA · GW

No, this is a fair point. I’m well off compared to many people (high savings), but I don’t have a high salary. I’m considering cheap places to live.

Comment by nananana.nananana.heyhey.anon on Where are the cool places to live where there is still *no* EA community? Bonus points if there is unlikely to be one in the future · 2022-05-11T13:11:38.227Z · EA · GW

This isn’t my experience in the US anymore! Most major cities have an EA meetup or it feels inevitable to me that they soon will. EA is still small overall, but increasingly ubiquitous. It’s a credit to the success of movement growth. It’s also a bit overwhelming for me. See comment below; even Tulsa is likely to have an EA group soon!

Comment by nananana.nananana.heyhey.anon on Where are the cool places to live where there is still *no* EA community? Bonus points if there is unlikely to be one in the future · 2022-05-11T11:26:48.341Z · EA · GW

This is true. I appreciate you taking a minute to make a supportive comment!

I got downvoted but I’m not hating on the community at all.

Even more than my previous IRL communities, EAs are consistently kind, interesting, share my values, and offer events that I think are likely to do some actual good. I am drawn to the real life EA community like moth to flame whenever there is one available. But it’s also not sustainable for me to be so involved in EA. That’s not the community’s fault. It’s a quirk of my own psychology.

I’d like to live somewhere sunny where IRL EA hangouts is not an option so I’m incentivized to make other connections.